Forming an LLC to hold a rental property is the easy part. The step investors underestimate is what happens to the existing mortgage and insurance policy the moment the deed actually moves from your name into the LLC’s — two separate risks that have nothing to do with liability shielding itself.
The Due-on-Sale Clause Is Real, Even If Rarely Enforced
Most conventional mortgages contain a due-on-sale clause giving the lender the right to demand full repayment if the property is transferred without the lender’s consent, and transferring title into an LLC is a transfer for this purpose. The federal Garn-St. Germain Act carves out several transfer types that can’t trigger acceleration — including a transfer into a trust where the borrower stays a beneficiary — but it does not explicitly exempt a transfer into an LLC, which leaves that specific transfer type outside the statute’s guaranteed protection.
Why Lenders Usually Don’t Call the Loan Anyway
In practice, lenders rarely invoke the due-on-sale clause when an owner transfers a performing loan into their own LLC and payments continue on schedule — the lender’s collateral position doesn’t actually change, and calling a current loan would be counterproductive for the lender. Fannie Mae’s own guidance, updated in 2017, explicitly permits servicers to waive the due-on-sale clause for a transfer into an LLC when the loan was purchased or securitized by Fannie Mae on or after June 1, 2016 and the LLC is controlled by, or the original borrower holds a majority interest in, the LLC receiving title. That guidance reduces but doesn’t eliminate the theoretical risk on loans outside those parameters.
Insurance Doesn’t Automatically Follow the Deed
A homeowners or landlord policy written to a person, not an entity, generally doesn’t extend coverage to a claim after the property is retitled into an LLC — the named insured on the policy has to match who actually owns the property for a claim to pay out cleanly. This is the step that gets missed most often: the deed transfer happens, but the insurance policy never gets updated to name the LLC as the insured, leaving a real coverage gap that isn’t obvious until there’s an actual claim.
Title Insurance Needs Its Own Fix
The original title insurance policy was written to insure the individual owner, and coverage under that specific policy may not extend to the LLC after a transfer, depending on how the title company defines “insured” in its policy language. A 107.9 or 107.10 endorsement is the specific fix — a rider that extends the existing title policy’s coverage to the LLC as the new titleholder, avoiding the cost of buying an entirely new title policy.
The Practical Order of Operations
Confirm the loan situation and any Fannie/Freddie guidance that applies before transferring, retitle the deed into the LLC, immediately update the property and liability insurance to name the LLC as the insured (not just add it as an additional insured), and get the title insurance endorsement processed — in that order, not deed-first-and-figure-out-insurance-later.
Affiliate Disclosure: This page may contain affiliate links. If you make a purchase or sign up through these links, we may earn a commission at no extra cost to you.
Related reading: Series LLCs Explained: One Entity, Multiple Liability Shields and Holding Company Structures: What They Actually Protect, and What They Cost.
Recent Comments